Nyfiken på Whisky ?
Varför inte en egen Whisky provning,  kolla här.

* States that there is some difference, e.g. the bottling year or the proof.
 

Back to:  Tasting matrix / Score order / Alphabet. order  / Date order / WSMS vs MJ-JM
     

WSMS

Jackson

 Murray

MM
Aberfeldy 11y, 43% 1991-2002, (cask nr6825, nr382 of 427) Signatory 78 - - -
Aberfeldy 23y, 57,9% 1973-1996, SMWS 60.15 SMWS 87 - - -
Aberlour 60,2% a'bunadh, Batch 8 OB

79

 86 88

87
  Ardbeg 59,9% 2006, Young Uigeadail "Oogling" OB 92 - - -
  Ardbeg 6y, 58,3% Very Young, 1998-2004 OB 90 - - 86
  Ardbeg 6y, 58,9% Very Young "for discussion" OB

90

 - -

85
  Ardbeg 8y, 56,2% Still Young 1998-2006 OB 90 - - 86
  Ardbeg 9y, 54,1% 2006, Almost There OB 90 - - -
  Ardbeg 54,2% Uigedail OB 90 - - 86
  Ardbeg  10y, 43% "Clear bottle" OB 83 - - 93
  Ardbeg 10y, 46% OB

85

 85 93

87
  Ardbeg 12y, 55,3% Committee Reserve (Bottled 2002) OB

88

 90 96

92
Ardbeg 1990, 55% OB 94 - - 90
Ardbeg 16y, 46% 1990-2006 "Airigh Nam Beist" OB 90 - - 91
Ardbeg 16y, 1990-2006, sample from Cask xxxx OB 92 - - -
Ardbeg 17y, 40% OB

90

 86 92 86
Ardbeg 21y, 56,3% Committee OB

94

 87 95 91
Ardbeg 23y, 55,6% 1974, Provenance, no4814 OB

95

 93* 96 91
Ardbeg 24y, 57,6% 1980, Kildalton Limited Edition OB

89

  - - 88
Ardbeg 25y, 46% Lord of the Isles OB

92

 89 87 91
  Ardbeg 40,9% 1975, Cask 4699 (121 bottles) OB 90 - - -
  Ardbeg 30y, 49,9% 1972-2003, "Velier" (Cask 2782) OB 94 - - 95
  Ardbeg 31y,  1975-2006, sample from Cask 4712 OB 92 - - -
  Ardbeg 31y, 49,3% 1973, Cask 1143 (216 bottles) OB 92 - - 89
  Ardbeg 31y, 48% 1974-2006, (Cask 4547) OB 95 - - -
  Ardbeg 32y, 48,5% 1972, Cask 868 (236 bottles) OB 95 - - 92
Ardbeg 40% 1995-2005, Connoissers Choice G & M

83

 - - -
  Ardbeg 9y, 49,8% 1996-2005, SOS Speymalt (Cask 924) G & M 89 - - -
Ardbeg 25y, 50% 1975, Old Malt Cask, One of 702 bottles Douglas Laing

78

 - 97 95
  Ardbeg 27y, 50% 1973, Old Malt Cask, One of 240 bottles Douglas Laing 92 - - 92
  Ardbeg 28y, 50% 1972, Old Malt Cask, One of 186 bottles Douglas Laing 92 - - 94
  Ardbeg  57% 1975-1987 Samaroli 88 - - 83
  Ardbeg  18y, 54,6% 1974-1993, Barrel Selection Wilson & Morgan 84 - - 93
  Ardbeg  18y, 54,9% 1974-1992, Authentic Collection CAD 85 - - 95
  Ardbeg  18y, 57,6% 1974-1992, Authentic Collection CAD 88 - - 96
  Ardmore 15y, 58,6% 1990-2005, (cask nr30013, nr36 of 189) Signatory 87 - - 87
  Ardmore 23y, 58,1% 1977, Cask1183 (nr181 of 306) Signatory 82 - - 83
  Ardmore 20y, 53,7% 1985-2005, SMWS 66.18 SMWS 82 - - -
  Aultmore  15y, 54,9% 1989-2005, Old Masters J MacArthur 82 - - -
  Ayrshire 32y, 46% 1975-2007, (Cask 556) Signatory 88 - - -
  Ayrshire 30y,48,9% 1975-2005 Wilson & Morgan 83 - - 85
  Balblair 10y, 40% OB 80 - - -
  Balblair 16y, 43% OB 82 78 78 81
  Ballechin  46%, First Edition OB 82 - - 83
Balvenie 10y, 40% OB

80

 85 90 80
Balvenie 12y, 43% Doublewood OB

86

 87 79 84
Balvenie 17y, 43% Islay Cask OB

88

 89 - 84
Balvenie 21y, 40% Portwood OB

91

 88 87 87
Balvenie 25y, 46,9% Cask 15213, Bottle no32 OB

88

 86 88 -
  Banff  21y, 57,1% 1982-2004, Rare Malts OB, Diageo 84 - - -
  Benriach 28y, 57,1% 1975-2004, (cask nr7221, nr89 of 208) Signatory 86 - - 89
  Bladnoch 15y, 52,4%, cask 2630, Bottle no 29 of 280 OB

86

 - - -
  Bladnoch 23y, 53,6% 1977, Rare Malts OB, Diageo 88 78 - 85
  Bladnoch 16y, 50% 1988-2005, Old Malt Cask Douglas Laing 85 - - -
     

WSMS

Jackson

 Murray

MM
  Blair Athol 12y, 43% Flora & Fauna OB

81

 78 77 77
Bowmore 40% Surf OB

79

 78 75 79
Bowmore 56% Cask Strength Vaults OB

81

 81 80 82
Bowmore 43% Darkest, Sherry Cask OB

84

 91 69 73
  Bowmore 12y, 40% OB 80 - 85 78
  Bowmore 16y, 51,8% 1989, Limited Edition OB 84 - - 84
  Bowmore 21y, 43% OB 89 - - 87
  Bowmore 11y, 60,9% 1995-2006, (Cask 20192) TSMoS 87 - - -
Brora 30y, 52,4% 1st Release, bottled 2002 OB

94

 86 - 91
Brora 30y, 55,7% 5th Release, Bottled 2006 OB

95

 - - -
Brora 23y, 57,3% 1981-2005, (Cask 1559) Signatory

90

 - - -
Brora 23y, 48% 1981-2005, (Cask 1512) Dun Bheagan Ian Macleod

90

 - - -
Brora 24y, 48,5% 1981-2006, (Cask 1524) Dun Bheagan Ian Macleod

91

 - - -
  Bruichladdich 10y, 46% OB 79 82 - 79
Bruichladdich 15y, 43% OB

84

 78 89* 80
Bruichladdich 20y, 46% Flirtation, Second Edition OB

85

 - - 86
Bunnahabhain 12y, 43% OB

80

 77 87 79
Bunnahabhain 16y, 50% 1985-2001, Old Malt Cask Douglas Laing

84

 - - -
  Caol Ila 8y, 59,8% "Unpeated" OB 84 - - 83
  Caol Ila 55% Cask Strength OB 87 85 91 88
  Caol Ila 43% 1993-2006, Moscatel Finished OB 85 - - 82
Caol Ila 18y, 43% OB

84

 86 77 86
  Caol Ila 13y, 60% 1992-2006, (Cask 12099) Galore   89 - - -
  Caol Ila  14y, 56,8% 1991-2005, (cask nr186) TSMoS 89 - - -
Caol Ila 15y, 58,8% 1991-2005, (cask nr100) TSMoS

88

 - - -
  Caperdonich 34y, 41,8% 1968, cask3568 (nr86 of 198) Duncan Taylor 79 - - -
  Clynelish 14y, 46% OB 83 81 86 84
  Clynelish 14y, 43% Flora & Fauna OB, Diageo

78

 81 86 80
  Clynelish 10y, 58,5% 1995-2006 Signatory 84 - - -
  Clynelish 10y, 58,9% 1995-2006 "The way of Spirit" J MacArthur 81 - - -
  Coleburn 21y, 59,4% 1979-2000, Rare Malts OB, Diageo 89 - - -
  Convalmore 24y, 59,4% 1978-2003, Rare Malts OB, Diageo 87 - - -
  Convalmore 22y, 50% 1978, Old Malt Cask Douglas Laing 93 - 80 90
  Cragganmore 12y, 40% OB 83 90 85 81
  Cragganmore 40% 1992, Distillers Edition OB 82 - - 77
  Cragganmore 15y, 55,7% 1989-2005, (Cask 987) Signatory 87 - - -
  Croftengea 8y, 45% 1997-2005 OB 72 - - -
  Dallas Dhu 22y, 46% "The Union of the Crowns" OB 87 - - -
  Dallas Dhu 10y, 40% G & M 76 - - -
  Dalmore 40% Cigar Malt OB

82

 81 71 79
Dalmore 12y, 40% OB

85

 79 91 75
  Dalwhinnie 15y, 43% OB 81 - - -
  Deanston 17y, 40% OB 75 71 68 74
Fuaran Ile 03/1991 - 06/2001, nr 0361, 46% Macleod

77

 - - -
  Glen Albyn  26y, 54,8% 1975-2002, Rare Malts OB, Diageo

87

 - - -
  Glen Albyn 21y, 40% 1972-1993, Connoissers Choice G & M

83

 - - -
  Glenburgie 10y, 40% G & M

78

 67 77 73
  Glen Deveron 10y, 40% 1990 OB

72

 72* 72* -
  Glen Deveron 10y, 40% 1993 OB

76

 - - -
  Glen Deveron 12y, 40% 1984 OB 76 75 86 -
     

WSMS

Jackson

 Murray

MM
Glendronach 12y, 40% OB

82

 - - 77
Glendronach 15y, 40% OB

85

 79 83 84
  Glendronach 18y, 43% 1976-1996 (bottle 001022) OB

85

 78 - -
  Glendullan 26y, 56,6% 1978-2005, Rare Malts OB, Diageo 86 - - -
  Glen Elgin 12y, 55,8% 1982-1995, SMWS 85.4 SMWS 87 - - -
  Glenesk 12y, 40% 1982-1994, Connoissers Choice G & M 78 - - -
  Glenesk 46,6% 1971, PNA (Part Nan Angelen) V&S 90 - - 89
  Glenfarclas 12y, 43% OB 81 - - 84
Glenfarclas 15y, 43% OB

84

 88 74 83
  Glenfarclas 40y, 54,7% 1964-2005 Norse Cask 81 - - -
Glenfiddich 12y, 40% Special Reserve OB

81

 77 80 77
Glenfiddich 12y, 40% Caoran Reserve OB

82

 82 84 78
Glenfiddich 15y, 43% Solera Reserve OB

80

  81 93 80
Glenfiddich 15y, 51% Cask Strength OB

83

  80 80 81
Glenfiddich 18y, 43% Ancient Reserve OB

82

  78 92 75
Glenfiddich 21y, 40% Grand Reserva OB

82

 86 75 80
Glenfiddich 30y, 40% OB

81

 86 85 84
  Glen Garioch 15y, 43% OB 76 79 79 84
  Glenglassaugh 51,2% 1976, cask2370 (nr179 of 280) Dormant Dist 81 - - 85
Glengoyne 17y, 43% OB

82

  78 76 82
Glengoyne 21y, 43% OB

88

 79 79 84
Glen Grant 40% OB

68

 74 89 71
Glen Grant 32y, 51,2% 1972-2004, (Cask 122) TSMoS

82

 - - -
Glenkinchie 10y, 43% OB

74

 76 80 77
Glenlivet 12y, 40% OB

79

 85 83 78
Glenlivet 21y, 43% Archive OB

88

 85 87 83
  Glenmorangie 43%, Sherry Wood Finish OB 82 - - 78
  Glenmorangie 43% Madeira wood Finish OB 80 - - 81
Glenmorangie 43% Port Wood Finish OB

82

 87 84 75
Glen Mhor 28y, 51,9% 1976-2005, Rare Malts OB, Diageo

87

 - - -
Glenrothes 43% 1989-2000 OB

80

 82 76 84
  Glen Scotia 13y, 40% 1990-2003, Collection, Refill Sherry G & M 77 - - 82
  Glen Scotia 43% 1991, PNA (Part Nan Angelen) V&S 83 - - -
  Glenury Royal 23y, 61,3% 1971 Rare Malts Cask OB, Diageo 86 80 - 89
     

WSMS

Jackson

 Murray

MM
  Hanyu 56,3% 1988-2006, (cask nr9204) Private Cask 91 - - 91
  Hazelburn 8y, 46% First Edition OB 84 - - 84
  Hazelburn 8y, 58,7% 1998-2006, "Springbank society" OB 84 - - 79
Highland Park 12y, 40% (2002 years bottle) OB

90

 90 92 85
  Highland Park 15y, 56,6% 1990-2005 Cask 6537 OB 85 - - 91
  Highland Park 16y, 40% OB 82 - - 84
Highland Park 18y, 43% OB

91

 92 95 87
Highland Park 1977, Bicentenary OB

94

 94 93 89
  Highland Park 30y, 48,1% OB

92

 - - 91
Ileach 40% Ian Macleod

83

 - 94 -
  Inverleven 27y, 51% 1977 Signatory 91 - - 88
  Jura 5y, 58,4% one of 336 bottles, cask19 For RMW 84 - - 78
Jura 21y, 40% OB

63

 80 78 82
Kinclaith 1967, 40% Connoissers Choice G & M

91

 - - -
Knockando  12y, 40% 100 Years Centenary OB

75

 - - -
Lagavulin 12y, 57,8% 2003, 3'rd release OB

87

 91 92* 85
Lagavulin 12y, 57,5% 2006, 6th release OB

91

 - - -
Lagavulin 16y, 43% OB

92

 95 88 89
Lagavulin 43% 1986, Distillers Edition (Pedro Ximenez) OB

91

 95* 86 87
  Lagavulin 25y, 57,2% 2002, (nr05090) OB 95 - 78 88
  Lagavulin 30y, 52,6% 2006 OB 92 - - 91
  Lagavulin 10y, 52% 1994, SWS000 Sherry Cask SWS 95 - - -
  Laphroaig 48% Quarter Cask OB</